265
Your signature can make a difference. Let’s build a fairer, more just legal system for all. – https://chng.it/s6xzgftQF8
On a somber day, the tragic news of Atul Subhash, a 34-year-old AI professional from Bengaluru, Karnataka, reverberated across the nation. Atul took his own life, leaving behind a detailed suicide note that not only chronicled his personal anguish but also exposed systemic issues within India’s legal framework. His note is a harrowing account of alleged harassment, corruption, and the profound failures of institutions meant to protect justice.
This article delves deeply into Atul’s experiences, the allegations he made against his estranged wife, her family, and certain judicial figures, and the broader implications for India’s legal and social systems.
Background of Atul Subhash
Professional Life:
- Atul was an accomplished AI professional based in Bengaluru, a city known as India’s Silicon Valley.
- His career demanded intellect, dedication, and a relentless pursuit of excellence, qualities that he exemplified.
Personal Life:
- Atul married Nikita Singhania in 2019, after meeting on Shaadi.com, a popular matrimonial website.
- Nikita is an MBA graduate and engineer, working as an AI Engineering Consultant at Accenture in Delhi.
- The couple had a son named Vyom, who was 4.5 years old at the time of Atul’s death.
Allegations Against His Wife and Her Family
Atul’s suicide note provides an exhaustive account of his tumultuous relationship with his wife and her family, detailing instances of alleged harassment, extortion, and legal manipulation.
1. Financial Extortion and Greed
- Initial Demands:
- Shortly after marriage, Atul faced demands from his wife and in-laws for substantial financial assistance.
- They requested 6 lakhs for every small occasion, including dresses, sarees, and gold sets worth 10 lakhs.
- Business Investments:
- Atul transferred over 15 lakhs to his mother-in-law Nisha Singhania and brother-in-law Anurag (alias Piyush) Singhania for business purposes, specifically to buy inventory off-season at a cheaper rate.
- He later discovered they intended to use this money to purchase a house worth 1 crore, leading to disputes.
- Additional Demands:
- They pressured Atul to invest an additional 50 lakhs and to support his brother-in-law’s cloud kitchen business idea.
- Atul was also asked to buy land in Jaunpur and accept their disputed property in lieu of 30 lakhs.
2. Filing of Multiple Legal Cases
Atul detailed a series of legal cases filed against him and his family by his wife, many of which he claimed were false and baseless:
- Criminal Cases:
- Case 201/2022: Alleging Section 302 (Murder), Section 377 (Unnatural Offences), Section 498A (Dowry Harassment), among others. This case was later withdrawn by his wife.
- Case 9536/2022: Included charges under Section 498A, 504, 506, 323, and Dowry Prohibition Act.
- Maintenance and Domestic Violence:
- Case 142/2022: CrPC 125 for maintenance, demanding 2 lakhs/month.
- Case 3806/2022 and 2615/2024: Domestic Violence cases with similar financial demands.
- High Court Petitions:
- Case 74265/2023 and 1403/2023: Filed in the Allahabad High Court to fast-track the maintenance and 498A cases.
- Withdrawal and Refiling:
- Atul pointed out that his wife withdrew some cases, citing reasons like being unaware of filing them, only to refile them later, causing further harassment.
3. Child Alienation
- Atul was denied any form of contact with his son Vyom for over three years.
- Despite multiple court applications and personal pleas, his wife refused to allow visitation or even video calls.
- He expressed deep sorrow over being alienated from his child, feeling that his son was being used as a tool for extortion.
4. Harassment and Threats
- Verbal and Physical Abuse:
- Atul alleged that his wife and mother-in-law verbally and physically abused his mother on 26th September 2021. An NCR (Non-Cognizable Report) was filed at Marathahalli Police Station.
- Smear Campaign:
- His in-laws allegedly spread false information among relatives, claiming Atul had epilepsy, beat his wife, and forced her to eat non-vegetarian food despite her being vegetarian.
- Financial Manipulation:
- His wife allegedly shared OTPs over WhatsApp, leading to unauthorized transfers from his account, which the judge later claimed were under his control.
5. Allegations of False Accusations
Atul firmly denied several serious allegations made against him:
- Dowry Demands:
- He refuted claims of demanding 10 lakhs as dowry, highlighting that his income was substantial, and such demands were baseless.
- Physical Abuse:
- Atul questioned the lack of any medical evidence or witnesses to support claims of physical abuse.
- Murder Accusations:
- His wife accused him of causing her father’s death by demanding dowry, which he refuted by pointing out that her father had long-term health issues.
- Unnatural Offences:
- Atul denied allegations under Section 377, stating their marriage was sexless and challenging the lack of evidence.
Allegations of Judicial Corruption
One of the most alarming aspects of Atul’s suicide note is the detailed allegations against Principal Family Court Judge, Jaunpur, Uttar Pradesh – Rita Kaushik (JO Code: UP5728) and court staff.
1. Demands for Bribes
- Atul alleged that Judge Rita Kaushik directly demanded a bribe of 5 lakhs on 21st March 2024 to settle the cases.
- The court’s Peshkar (clerk), Madhav , allegedly demanded bribes ranging from 50 to 3 lakhs for various court favors, including getting favorable dates and judgments.
2. Bias and Unfair Practices
- Manipulation of Cross-Examinations:
- The judge allegedly manipulated cross-examination records, omitting or altering Atul’s statements to favor his wife.
- Rejection of Jurisdiction Applications:
- Atul’s applications challenging the court’s jurisdiction were dismissed without proper consideration.
- Non-Adherence to Legal Procedures:
- Evidence submissions were mishandled, and Atul was denied the opportunity to properly cross-examine.
- Immediate Orders Without Due Process:
- On 10th April 2024, the judge passed orders favoring his wife without allowing Atul to file a reply.
3. Instigation to Suicide
- During a court proceeding, Atul recounted an incident where his wife told him to “commit suicide” in the presence of Judge Rita Kaushik, who allegedly laughed and dismissed his concerns.
4. Observations on Corruption
- Atul described the corruption in the court as rampant, with bribes being openly exchanged in front of the judge.
- He expressed frustration over the financial and emotional toll this corruption took on him and his family.
Systemic Issues Highlighted
Atul’s tragic story brings to light several systemic flaws within India’s legal and social systems.
1. Misuse of Matrimonial Laws
- Section 498A and Others:
- Originally intended to protect women from dowry harassment and abuse, these laws are sometimes misused to harass husbands and their families.
- Atul’s case exemplifies how false allegations can lead to severe legal and personal consequences.
2. Corruption in the Judiciary
- Erosion of Trust:
- Allegations of bribery and favoritism in the judiciary undermine public confidence in the legal system.
- When justice can be influenced by money, it compromises the very foundation of law and order.
3. Gender Bias in Legal Proceedings
- Rights of Men Overlooked:
- Atul felt that the legal system was biased against men, particularly in matrimonial disputes.
- He questioned why his income was considered before tax for maintenance calculations and why his evidence was dismissed or manipulated.
4. Child Custody and Parental Rights
- Alienation from Children:
- The denial of access to his son caused Atul profound distress.
- The legal system’s failure to enforce visitation rights raises concerns about the rights of fathers and the best interests of the child.
5. Mental Health and Emotional Toll
- Lack of Support Mechanisms:
- Prolonged legal battles and personal harassment can have severe mental health implications.
- Atul’s despair highlights the need for better support systems for individuals undergoing such stress.
Atul’s Final Wishes and Reflections
In his note, Atul outlined specific final wishes and made poignant reflections on his situation:
1. Justice and Accountability
- Investigation into Allegations:
- He called for thorough investigations into the actions of his wife, her family, and Judge Kaushik.
- Punishment for Wrongdoers:
- Atul urged that those responsible for his harassment be held accountable to prevent future injustices.
2. Custody of His Son
- Guardianship to His Parents:
- Believing his parents could provide better values and upbringing, he wished for them to be granted custody of Vyom.
3. Public Awareness
- Transparency in Proceedings:
- He requested that all his case hearings be conducted live to expose the systemic issues.
- Use of Suicide Note and Videos:
- Atul wanted his note and accompanying videos to serve as evidence and raise public awareness.
4. No Settlements
- Rejection of Mediation:
- He insisted that there be no negotiations or settlements with his wife unless she admitted to filing false cases.
5. Reflections on Society and Legal Systems
- Disillusionment with Institutions:
- Atul expressed deep dissatisfaction with societal norms, legal frameworks, and the judiciary.
- Questioning Gender Dynamics:
- He challenged the notion of automatic victimhood based on gender and called for fairness irrespective of gender.
A Father’s Message to His Son
Atul penned a heartfelt message to his son, Vyom:
- Conflicted Emotions:
- He expressed love for his son but also pain over how their relationship was weaponized against him.
- Hopes for the Future:
- Atul wished for Vyom to understand the truth about his father and the circumstances that led to his death.
- Life Lessons:
- He advised his son to be wary of societal systems, to value individual sovereignty, and to live with confidence and pride.
Questions Raised by Atul
Atul posed several critical questions, reflecting his frustration and seeking answers:
- Are the false cases filed against me and my family being addressed appropriately?
- Is corruption a daily affair in the courts, and what is being done about it?
- Why is a father’s right to see his child being overlooked?
- How can serious allegations proceed without substantial evidence?
- Why is there a lack of accountability for those misusing legal provisions?
- Are family courts effectively saving or destroying families?
Broader Implications and Call for Reforms
Atul’s tragic story is not an isolated incident but reflects broader systemic issues:
1. Legal Reforms Needed
- Preventing Misuse of Laws:
- Implement safeguards to prevent the misuse of laws like Section 498A, ensuring they protect genuine victims without allowing for harassment.
- Judicial Accountability:
- Establish independent bodies to investigate allegations of corruption within the judiciary.
- Gender-Neutral Laws:
- Consider reforms that ensure fairness and justice irrespective of gender.
2. Mental Health Support
- Accessible Services:
- Provide mental health resources for individuals undergoing legal stress and personal crises.
- Awareness Campaigns:
- Promote understanding of mental health issues and encourage seeking help without stigma.
3. Child Custody and Parental Rights
- Equal Rights for Parents:
- Ensure that both parents have fair access to their children, prioritizing the child’s best interests.
- Enforcement of Visitation Rights:
- Strengthen mechanisms to enforce court-ordered visitation and penalize non-compliance.
4. Public Awareness and Dialogue
- Breaking the Silence:
- Encourage open discussions about the challenges faced by men in matrimonial disputes.
- Support Networks:
- Develop community support groups to provide assistance and guidance.
Conclusion
The untimely death of Atul Subhash is a profound tragedy that underscores significant flaws within India’s legal and social systems. His detailed account serves as a powerful plea for justice, fairness, and systemic reform. As a society, we must reflect on these issues and take concrete steps to prevent such tragedies in the future.
Atul’s story is a stark reminder of the human cost of systemic failures. It is incumbent upon us to ensure that his death was not in vain but serves as a catalyst for meaningful change.
Call to Action
- For Authorities:
- Conduct thorough and impartial investigations into the allegations raised by Atul.
- Implement necessary reforms to address corruption and inefficiencies in the judiciary.
- For Legal Professionals:
- Advocate for balanced laws that protect all parties in matrimonial disputes.
- Provide pro bono services to those unable to afford legal representation.
- For Society:
- Foster open dialogue about mental health and legal harassment.
- Support individuals facing such challenges, encouraging them to seek help.
Resources and Support
If you or someone you know is experiencing mental health challenges or facing harassment:
- National Helpline Numbers:
- Kiran Mental Health Rehabilitation Helpline: 1800-599-0019
- AASRA (Suicide Prevention): +91-9820466726
- Organizations:
Seeking help is a sign of strength. You are not alone.
Disclaimer: This article is based on the contents of a suicide note and allegations made therein. All individuals mentioned are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The aim is to shed light on the systemic issues highlighted and encourage constructive dialogue and reform.
