BLUEFIELD, WV (LOOTPRESS) – A string of burglaries at an old church in Bluefield has led to the unraveling of a wider theft and drug-fueled crime ring, resulting in multiple arrests and a growing list of criminal charges.
On May 19, 2025, Patrolman S.D. Copenhaver responded to a theft report at 1415 Bland Street, the site of the Greater Tabernacle of Faith, which was being prepped for renovations. The property’s owner, Anderson Martin, reported that numerous antique items, including lamps, heaters, a drum set, furniture, and copper piping, had been stolen.
Investigators believe the suspects entered through an unsecured basement door. A trailer filled with stolen items was later traced to Herman Hancock’s father, and more stolen property was found near the Hancock residence.
The case soon pointed to Frankie Pennington, who was also linked to other ongoing investigations. Pennington’s girlfriend, Jessica Scott, revealed that he had been breaking into the church repeatedly to fund his drug addiction—often using a dolly and chain to remove large items. She also named Herman Hancock as an accomplice.
On June 8, Pennington was arrested at his Preston Street apartment and confessed to breaking into the church at least eight times, often accompanied by Hancock and another man, James Garrett. The group sold stolen copper at Princeton Recycle, netting over $1,000.
Pennington also admitted to breaking into cars around Bluefield and stealing tools from a separate home burglary.
James Garrett later turned himself in and admitted to taking part in at least four church break-ins. He also confessed to possessing a stolen firearm, despite a previous felony conviction. A search of his home uncovered a loaded weapon and more stolen property.
Warrants have been issued for:
Eight counts of entering without breaking
Conspiracy
Grand larceny
Burglary
Petit larceny
Charges are also being filed against Hancock and Garrett, with more arrests expected.
A stash house on Vine Street was later identified, where more of the church’s stolen property was recovered. The investigation remains ongoing as authorities continue to retrieve stolen items and pursue additional suspects.
