DAUPHIN COUNTY, Pa. — Sonya McKnight, a suspended Dauphin County judge, has been convicted of attempted murder and aggravated assault after she shot her then-boyfriend, Michael McCoy, in the head in February 2024.
Following a brief deliberation of less than two hours, the jury returned a guilty verdict on Wednesday morning, ending the trial at the Dauphin County Courthouse. The shooting occurred on the morning of February 10, 2024, when McKnight shot McCoy while he was sleeping in bed.
The Shooting Incident
During the trial, McCoy testified that the last conversation he had with McKnight was on February 9, when he told her he wanted her to move out. McCoy said McKnight reacted by saying, “oh, so you’re serious.” He allowed her to stay in the master bedroom that night, and the next morning, McCoy woke up in excruciating pain, not realizing he’d been shot until EMS informed him.
McCoy underwent two surgeries following the shooting, and an ophthalmologist confirmed that McCoy would require lifelong medical care for his vision, which was severely affected.
Forensic Evidence and Testimonies
The prosecution presented substantial forensic evidence, including gunshot residue found on both McCoy’s clothing and McKnight’s hand and clothing, linking McKnight to the shooting.
The trial also featured 17 witnesses, including police officers and forensic scientists, who testified about the investigation into the shooting.
Defense and Sentencing
McKnight’s defense attorney, Cory Leshner, disagreed with the jury’s decision and announced plans to appeal. Despite the verdict, McKnight’s defense argued her innocence.
The judge set McKnight’s bail at $3 million, and she was immediately transported to the Dauphin County Prison following the verdict. McKnight is scheduled for a sentencing hearing on May 28.
Looking Ahead
This case has attracted significant public attention, and McKnight’s future as a judge remains uncertain. The Dauphin County Court has yet to announce any actions regarding her judicial standing following the conviction.
